Return to Recent Articles
 

 Abstracts of Articles
 


Thwarting the Diversity Backlash

Martha Frase-Blunt,
HR Magazine June 2003, Vol. 48 Issue 6, pp. 137-143.


The term "diversity" seems to be everywhere these days. But what does diversity really mean, and how can it benefit employers and workplaces? How do recent court cases challenging affirmative action and alleging reverse discrimination influence how employers handle diversity programs?

A reverse discrimination lawsuit brought against Eastman Kodak last year by a white male middle manager highlights the importance of implementing and communicating diversity programs that emphasize the benefits of diversity to all members of an organization, not just racial or gender minorities. Martha Frase-Blunt points out that like Eastman Kodak, organizations that "frame diversity in terms of racial or gender discrimination…are in danger of fomenting employee resentment-if not lawsuits-which surfaces as low morale, high turnover and poor productivity."

So if diversity is not about racial or gender discrimination, what is it about? Fundamentally, diversity means "honoring and actualizing individual differences, including those of the so-called majority-white males," says Sondra Thiederman, president of Cross-Cultural Communications, a San Diego-based consulting firm. Diversity is not the same as affirmative action, which is quantitative and focuses on recruiting and hiring people of specific races, genders, or cultures. Instead, diversity is qualitative and seeks to "maximize potential for all employees".

Texas Instruments (TI) of Dallas is one example of an organization that has embraced the spirit of diversity in its "business resource groups," which include groups for Muslims, single parents, gays and lesbians, blacks, women, and Indians, among others. The key to these groups' success has been their inclusive nature: "Our women's groups have male members. The executive sponsor of the black employees' groups is a white male," says Terry Howard, TI's diversity director. "I'm a member of our gay and lesbian group, even though I'm straight." These groups are not simply for social networking, however; the company insists that each group function for business purposes and contribute to the company's success.

Frase-Blunt emphasizes that organizations must link diversity initiatives to the bottom line. Turnover and retention, recruitment, productivity, salary equity, and advancement are all indicators of how successful a company is at managing diversity issues; if diversity is not valued or is mishandled, all of these factors will suffer. Diversity must be presented to the organization in this light, says Todd Campbell of the Society for Human Resource Management. "The key message should center on what's in it for them, even to the point of demonstrating the positive impact on stock prices, corporate image and the ability to attract the best and brightest candidates from all groups. Point out that this correlates to company profits, and, therefore, job security and rewards."

This article would be helpful for any manager seeking to better understand what diversity means in today's workplace.