Return to Recent Articles
 

 Abstracts of Articles
 


The Young and the Clueless

Kerry A. Bunker, Kathy Kram and Sharon Ting

Harvard Business Review
Dec. 2002, Vol 80, Issue 12, p. 80


This is an interesting article about emotional intelligence. Emotional intelligence is a newly coined term that suggests that someone has highly successful interpersonal skills, a characteristic which many believe is at the heart of most individual and organizational success.

It seems only natural for companies to want to promote their young, ambitious managers. The authors of this article argue that premature promotion can rob an aggressive potential leader of the time it may take him or her to develop emotional competencies. "The problem is a lack of emotional maturity which doesn't come easily or automatically and isn't something you learn from a book."

The article looks at five strategies for boosting emotional intelligence. First, one encourages employers to deepen the 360-degree feedback process. The 360 process would require feedback from a wide variety of the manager's peers and subordinates. The process would record the feedback, and let the manager read and reflect upon the answers. The process can be an eye opener for anyone, let alone someone with great enthusiasm, but sometimes lacking introspection.

A second strategy would interrupt the ascent. Instead of promoting the young star, employers would give him an alternate assignment where he or she uses cross-functional skills, and where the person cannot rely on rank to influence people. This would help the person to get beyond the command-and-control mentality. He or she would develop negotiation and persuasion skills.

The third piece of advice is to act on your own commitment. Show the young manager that emotional skills and the ability to work with others are essential. If he has erred, force the person to confront his co-workers, apologize if necessary, and talk about new strategies. In some cases, the employer should take a tough stance by denying the young manager a promotion, but with the promise that changed behavior in getting along well with others will be rewarded.

Fourth, employers are asked to Institutionalize personal development. This requires the organization to make emotional competence a performance measure; and, If necessary in extreme cases, assign a coach to a manager. This coach will observe him or her with employees, and provide advice if he or she is being too blunt or aggressive. The young manager must be made to see that emotional skills constitute a key qualification as far as promotion is concerned.

Finally, the authors suggest the cultivation of informal networks. Many employees will benefit from a network of peer relationships that fall outside the company hierarchy. Mentoring can be a very positive experience for all concerned, and can extend outside the workplace. It can give junior managers a chance to experience different leadership styles and exposes them to different viewpoints.

Often highly motivated, extremely intelligent young managers can be arrogant. This sensible article addresses the practical aspect of teaching them how to get down to earth and how to communicate with others in the workplace.



  Copyright, 2002, Antone Aboud Associates, Inc.